As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

comparison

Three concealers for dark circles

I own all three. Here's when I reach for each one.

All three concealers on my counter, with swatches on my arm, top to bottom: tarte Colored Clay CC corrector, Clinique Even Better Eraser, tarte Shape Tape Blur
My own photo. The swatches, top to bottom: tarte CC Corrector, Clinique Even Better, tarte Shape Tape Blur.

The short answer

Every day
The Clinique Even Better. It's the one I put on every morning, and it still looks like my skin.
When my dark circles are darker
First the tarte CC, then the Clinique on top. Or the tarte CC on its own, depending on the color of your dark circles. If they're not that dark, I use only the Clinique.
For photos or events
The tarte Shape Tape Blur, when I want more coverage.
tarte Colored Clay CC Undereye Corrector, Light-Medium Peach I use this

tarte CC Corrector

tarte Colored Clay CC Undereye Corrector, Light-Medium Peach

My peach corrector: with the Clinique on darker days, or all on its own.

View on Amazon

#ad · Affiliate link: if you purchase through this link, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Read my full review
Clinique Even Better All-Over Concealer + Eraser, Alabaster CN 10 I use this

Clinique Even Better

Clinique Even Better All-Over Concealer + Eraser, Alabaster CN 10

My every day. It covers my dark circles and still looks like skin.

View on Amazon

#ad · Affiliate link: if you purchase through this link, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Read my full review
tarte Shape Tape Blur Concealer Stick, Full Size, 12N I use this

tarte Shape Tape Blur

tarte Shape Tape Blur Concealer Stick, Full Size, 12N

Looks like a lipstick. The diamond precision tip lifts the eye.

View on Amazon

#ad · Affiliate link: if you purchase through this link, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Read my full review

I have three concealers on my counter, and each one has its own moment. The Clinique is my every day. The tarte CC comes out when my dark circles are darker, and depending on their color, it can also do the job all on its own. And the Shape Tape Blur is for photos and events. Here's how I use each one, in my own words.

How the 3 products compare, in Angie's words
tarte CC CorrectorClinique Even Bettertarte Shape Tape Blur
What it isA creamy, peach-toned corrector for dark circles. I wear it before the Clinique, but depending on the color of your dark circles, it can go on its own.My everyday concealer, with skincare ingredients, per Clinique.My full-coverage concealer, for when I want more.
CoverageVery good.High and complete, and it still looks like skin.The highest of the three. It covers everything.
FinishCreamy. It looks lovely on its own, or with the Clinique on top.Natural and light.More matte, more perfected.
Lines under the eyeFine if I go lightly. Too much and it looks heavy.It stays flexible and moves when my face moves.It can settle into the lines if I use too much.
When I use itOn days my dark circles are darker, before the Clinique. Or on its own, if it's all your dark circles need.Every day, on its own or over the tarte CC.A party, a special event, or a photo.

Every line above is my own observation on my own skin, except where I say the brand claims it.

More detail on all three
Further comparison details
tarte CC CorrectorClinique Even Bettertarte Shape Tape Blur
TextureCreamy, and it blends without dragging the skin.More liquid, light and hydrating.The most pigmented of my three. The diamond tip glides on very smoothly and covers imperfections.
What the brand highlightstarte lists vegan squalane and caffeine, and describes it as waterproof.Clinique highlights vitamin C, hyaluronic acid and caffeine.tarte describes it as creamy and buildable, with medium-to-full coverage.
In my purseA tiny square. It fits anywhere, and it disappears in there.Practical to carry. It comes with me.Practical too, and it looks like a lipstick in the bag.
Where I put itWhere I need it most, or across the whole under-eye, depending on the color of your dark circles. Always just a little.The whole under-eye, on its own or over the tarte CC.The whole under-eye, on its own.

Angie's verdict

The Clinique is my every day. It's the one I wouldn't give up. It looks the most natural of the three, it never feels heavy, and with daily use my under-eye looks more even.

On darker days, the tarte CC goes on first. Just a little, and then the Clinique on top. That way the Clinique only has to even things out, and I use less product. Less product under the eye always looks better. And if the tarte CC alone is all your dark circles need, that's beautiful too.

The Shape Tape Blur is for the camera. When I want more coverage for a photo or an event, this is the one: full coverage, more matte, more perfected. I save it for those moments.

If you only buy one

If you only buy one, make it the Clinique. It's the one you'll use every day. If your dark circles get darker some days, the tarte CC goes first and the Clinique on top, or the tarte CC on its own, depending on the color of your dark circles. And if you want more coverage for photos or events, the Shape Tape Blur is the one.

The honest part

A few things I learned on my own skin. With the Shape Tape Blur, less is more: if I put on too much, it settles into the lines under my eyes. With the tarte CC, a little goes a long way. I wear it before my Clinique on the days my dark circles are darker, but every under-eye is different. Depending on the color of your dark circles, the tarte CC can do a beautiful job all on its own, across the whole under-eye or wherever you need it most, with nothing else on top. And it's so easy to carry… though, truth be told, all three are practical. The Clinique covers really well, and it's perfect for every day. And for a special event, when I want a super perfected, long-lasting finish, that's when I reach for the Shape Tape Blur.

Updated: September 25, 2026

See all of Angie's picks